Government urged not to limit pension freedoms

Financial professionals have warned against restricting pension freedoms while the government finalizes its proposed guided retirement framework. The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) released its consultation on these new rules, mandating that all defined contribution (DC) pension schemes provide a standard withdrawal option for members accessing their retirement savings by default.
The consultation, published in partnership with the Pensions Regulator and the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), is open until 22 December. Pensions minister Torsten Bell said the government was “resurrecting proper pensions” and that guided retirement would offer people “the option of an income that lasts throughout retirement and, in many cases, protection against the rising cost of living”.
Steve Webb, partner at LCP and former pensions minister, praised the guided retirement concept but urged the government not to overpromote lifetime income offerings at the expense of individual choice. “There is a danger that the government’s hostility to pension freedoms will lead them to promote ‘lifetime income’ solutions too heavily,” Webb said.
Guided Retirement Rules
Jon Greer, head of retirement policy at Quilter, said that default retirement solutions can help, particularly for those who do not want to make complex decisions themselves. However, he emphasized that people must retain the flexibility to choose a different approach and access personalized advice where appropriate. “Defaults made auto-enrolment work, and we support them at retirement too, but designing a default for retirement is much harder than designing one for saving,” Greer said.
Several pension providers, including Nest and Aviva, have already established or are working on post-retirement systems for members who do not make a decision when they reach retirement age. These systems are designed to reduce the pressure on individuals to make significant, irreversible financial decisions in a short timeframe or without any support.
Yvonne Braun, director of long-term savings policy at the Association of British Insurers, agreed that it was “important that people continue to have the freedom to make their own decisions”. She added that the government and FCA’s plans were a step in the right direction, but that the details of the rules would be essential to their success. Mark Futcher, head of DC pensions at Howden Employee Benefits, said that preserving choice was essential, as people needed both a secure foundation and room to adapt.
He also suggested that the government should revisit drawdown rules, which require a minimum annual income of £12,000 to access flexible arrangements. Recent research by Standard Life found that only a third of people aged 50 and over felt confident making decisions about turning their pension pot into an income.
Emma Furlonger, managing director of workplace and retail intermediary at Standard Life, argued that default options should be designed as “an important guardrail” rather than replacing engagement efforts. Kathryn Fleming, head of DC consulting at Hymans Robertson, said that the consultation was “an important next step in moving away from a world where millions of savers are expected to become retirement experts, just at the point they reach one of the most complex financial decisions of their lives”.
She emphasized that guided retirement would only fulfill its potential if the end results genuinely improved the member experience. The DWP and regulators published examples of how an individual could be guided through the retirement process, including what providers should do if people do not engage.
Joe Dabrowski, of Smart Pension, emphasized the importance of considering how retirement is changing when designing default retirement solutions. The goal is to create a system that supports individuals throughout their retirement journey. Default options should be designed to provide a safety net, rather than restricting individual choice.