Merger Briefs

Industry welcomes draft fiduciary duty guidance

By Gracia Septiani November 21, 2026
Industry welcomes draft fiduciary duty guidance - fiduciary duty guidance
Minister Torsten Bell promised the guidance amid heated discussions on mandating provisions in the Pension Schemes Bill.

Industry groups have largely welcomed a draft guidance on fiduciary duty released this week, aimed at giving trustees clearer direction when making investment choices. The consultation remains open until January 28 2027 and is positioned as a clarification, not a legal amendment, meaning that existing rules stay in force while the new text offers interpretive help.

The paper explains that it does not create fresh obligations or alter the current duty that trustees already carry.

“Fiduciary duty is there as a constant in the law. But as circumstances and experience develop, so too the way in which fiduciary and related duties work is further illuminated,” wrote Sir Robin Knowles, chair of both the Technical Working Group and the Advisory Group that drafted the material.

Minister Torsten Bell promised the guidance amid heated discussions on mandating provisions in the Pension Schemes Bill. He later asked Sir Robin and a panel of experts to prepare the draft that is now under public review, signalling governmental support for the initiative.

“Every day, trustees make decisions that shape the retirement of millions of people, and they deserve clear support to make those with confidence and to ultimately deliver the best possible results for savers,” the minister said, showing the policy’s focus on protecting pension members.

Areas of uncertainty addressed

The consultation highlights recurring sources of doubt, including sustainability-related issues, system-level risks such as climate change, nature and biodiversity, and broader geopolitical developments that could affect long-term returns.

It also examines factors that may influence members’ future living costs and the challenges of deciding under incomplete information, noting that trustees often lack reliable data on emerging risks.

“The challenge is often not in identifying the relevant legal duties themselves, but in understanding how those duties should be applied in practice when making complex investment decisions within an evolving investment environment,” the paper notes, emphasizing the need for practical guidance.

Legal and regulatory foundations

The draft aligns with existing trust law, case law and the regulatory regimes that govern pension schemes, ensuring that it does not conflict with any statutory provision.

It draws heavily on the Law Commission’s 2014 report on fiduciary duties of investment intermediaries and the Financial Markets Law Committee’s guidance on trustee decision-making around sustainability and climate-related financial risks, linking the new advice to well-established authorities.

“For several years, we have been calling for greater clarity that pension trustees can take a longer-term view and consider system-level implications when making investment decisions,” the document reads, echoing long-standing industry calls for more subtle rules.

Stakeholder reactions

“Fiduciary duty is capable of encompassing a wide range of issues where financially material. In assessing financial materiality, human judgement and narrative can be just as valuable as numbers,” said Andy Lewis of Sackers, who highlighted the importance of qualitative insight.

Claire Brinn of ShareAction argued that the law should better allow trustees to consider member views and the impact of investments on retirees’ living standards, urging a more member-centric approach.

Diandrah Soobiah of Nest said “[The guidance] will support trustees to consider financially material factors such as climate change, nature, social issues, and wider systemic risks where these may affect members’ long-term outcomes. By providing greater certainty around the existing framework, the guidance supports trustees in exercising their judgement while keeping strong financial outcomes for members firmly at the heart of every decision.”

Stuart O’Brien, also of Sackers, said “There is a lot here for the industry to digest. But trustees should not read the draft as requiring an immediate wholesale revision of existing arrangements. What matters is identifying financially material considerations, taking appropriate advice and following careful and proportionate processes to reach the best overall decisions for members.”

The consultation is open until the deadline.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2026 Univest Corp. All rights reserved.